Myth vs Mud - What Archaeology Tells Us About the Knights Templar

Aerial view of the commandery of Jalès in the Ardèche
Popular images show Templar commanderies as fortified strongholds of warrior monks. Excavations in France and England over the past fifty years tell a different story of farms, chapels, workshops and cemeteries. Can the material evidence finally separate the historical commandery from the myth?

Walls and Towers Came Later
A review of three decades of French excavations at Templar and Hospitaller commanderies, published in 2008, showed that the houses were often built on defensible or previously occupied sites, such as islands, mottes or raised ground; Corbeil stood on an island in the Essonne and La Salvetat on an artificial mound above the Garonne [1]. The substantial walls, towers and moats that impress visitors today, however, mostly date from the Hundred Years War or later, often from the fifteenth century reorganisation by the Hospitallers [1]. Fontsèche had only palisades and simple drainage ditches, and Jalès kept the look of an open farm until the Hundred Years War [1]. A rural commandery typically had two courtyards, one for farming and one around the chapel and living quarters [1]. Regional studies confirm this picture. At La Cavalerie in the Gers, a commandery documented in 1264, the remains consist of a Romanesque chapel, a tower house, a granary and farm buildings inside an enclosure protected by a ditch on one side [2]. There was no Templar architectural type: builders followed local practice [2].

Farms, Mills and Workshops
Daily life was dominated by work. French sites have produced bread ovens, forges, traces of tanning, water installations and grain silos, for example at La Salvetat and Fontsèche; the pottery is mostly regional and points to modest consumption [1]. The animal bones at Fontsèche show a rural diet dominated by beef, and the silos at Bajoles held abundant plant remains [1]. Lance and arrow heads from La Salvetat and Fontsèche, with horse harness and spurs, support the picture of militarised religious [1]. In England the preceptory of South Witham in Lincolnshire, founded before 1164 and excavated between 1965 and 1967, revealed halls, a chapel, an aisled barn, a watermill with millpond, fishponds, a smithy and workshops for metal and tiles around a farmyard [3].

Chapels and Cemeteries
Commandery chapels were simple in form but served many functions [1]. In towns they were often enlarged or rebuilt from the thirteenth century, while many rural chapels kept their Romanesque style [1]. Cemeteries were open to the laity, with men, women and children of all ages [1]. Several contain a striking number of infants, at Corbeil, Toulouse and L'Argentière-la-Bessée, which may point to charitable roles towards the local population, although high infant mortality is another explanation [1]. The cemetery of the Hospitaller grand priory at Toulouse held more than 1,800 burials [1]. People buried in the Toulouse cloister were little exposed to stress and food shortage and lived around forty years, and the Corbeil remains point to a privileged community spared heavy physical work [1]. At 'Atlit in the Holy Land, the excavated cemetery of nearly 2,000 graves includes soldiers, pilgrims, residents and local Christians [4].

The evidence suggests that most commanderies were agricultural and religious centres, integrated into regional economies, with defences that were modest in the Templar period and grew only later. The mud, in other words, does not support the myth of the fortress, although archaeology has so far touched only a small share of the sites, and Carraz himself urges combining the finds with written sources [1].

This blog, an improved version of an earlier one, is original work by TemplarsNowTM based on an AI-assisted quick scan on the topic. References and further reading, Open Access if available, all links verified October 4, 2026 and all sources checked but not all studied in detail: [1] Carraz, D. (2008) Archéologie des commanderies de l'Hôpital et du Temple en France (1977-2007), Cahiers de recherches médiévales 15, pp. 175-202; [2] Ramis, P. (2011) Les commanderies templières du Gers: étude archéologique, master's thesis, Université Toulouse II Le Mirail; [3] Historic England (n.d.) Remains of Knights Templar preceptory, watermill and fishponds, South Witham, National Heritage List for England, entry 1007688; [4] CNRS News (2018) An Ancient Crusader Cemetery, on the excavations led by Yves Gleize

The illustration shows an aerial view of the Commanderie de Jalès at Berrias-et-Casteljau (Ardèche), seen from the north west. Photo Barge, CC BY-SA 3.0, source Wikimedia Commons. - cv03 -

Support TemplarsNow™ by becoming a Patron, tipping us or buying one of our Reliable Books
or other products at Amazon or Bol via our affiliate links amazon.com and bol.com

No comments: